Scuff-X, a product by Benjamin Moore, has garnered significant attention in the professional painting community. This review delves into the experiences of professional decorators with Scuff-X, evaluating its performance, application, and comparison with competitors like Aqua Guard.
Experiences and Recommendations
Kitchen Cupboards Debate
Piers Martin started a discussion about using Scuff-X for kitchen cupboards, despite some initial disagreement. The Benjamin Moore technical advice team confirmed that Scuff-X, especially in Satin finish or above, is suitable for kitchen cabinet doors. Recommendations for the best brush and roller combo included Oval Ice Fusion brushes and Two Fussy Blokes rollers, praised for their ability to achieve a smooth finish.
Brush and Roller Insights
Joe Harris and Ben Collins recommended Oval Ice Fusion brushes and Two Fussy Blokes rollers, respectively, highlighting their effectiveness in achieving a smooth, professional finish.
Jamie Daniels and Mark Johnson noted that Scuff-X’s quality allows for excellent results even with more basic tools, underscoring the paint’s user-friendly nature.
Application and Performance
Self-Leveling Properties
Daniel Evans highlighted Scuff-X’s remarkable self-leveling properties, which make it easier to apply compared to other paints like Aqua Guard. This characteristic was echoed by other decorators who appreciated the smooth, spray-like finish achievable with Axus Silk 4” rollers and Two Fussy Blokes mini rollers.
Durability and Quick Drying
Richard Green and Mike Walker praised Scuff-X for its durability, ease of application, and quick drying time. Walker emphasized that Scuff-X dries hard within an hour or two, allowing for same-day recoating, which is a significant time-saver for professionals.
Chris Davies’ extensive tests showed that while Scuff-X performs well, Aqua Guard demonstrated superior long-term durability, particularly in high-traffic areas and against hand oils and dog collars.
Comparing with Competitors
Aqua Guard and Other Alternatives
Many decorators, including Tim Roberts and Simon Clarke, preferred Johnstone’s Aqua Guard for its cost-effectiveness and durability. Chris Davies’ tests supported this preference, showing Aqua Guard’s superior performance in high-wear situations. Alternatives like Teknos Futura and Tikkurila, favoured by Michael Williams for woodwork, were also mentioned as competitive options.
Cost and Value
Scuff-X’s high price was a recurring topic of debate. John Sullivan expressed skepticism about its value, seeking empirical data on its durability. However, some decorators noted that sales and promotions, like those at Brewers, made Scuff-X more affordable. Despite the cost, users like Richard Green felt that Scuff-X’s ease of application and longevity justified the investment.
Practical Feedback
Real-World Use and Customer Satisfaction
Chris Bell and Kevin Morgan appreciated Scuff-X for its bright whiteness and consistent finish, with many customers commenting positively on the results.
Decorators like Andy Lewis found Scuff-X to be easy to use and effective, with quick recoats and satisfactory final appearances.
Durability in High-Traffic Areas
While some decorators, such as Andrew Walker, reported excellent durability of Scuff-X in high-traffic areas, Chris Davies’ long-term tests suggested that Aqua Guard might offer better performance in such conditions. This underscores the importance of selecting the right product based on specific project needs.
Conclusion
Scuff-X by Benjamin Moore stands out for its ease of application, quick drying time, and impressive finish. While it is more expensive than some competitors, many decorators find its performance justifies the cost, especially when considering time savings and customer satisfaction. However, for high-traffic areas or surfaces exposed to oils and frequent contact, alternatives like Aqua Guard may offer better durability. Overall, Scuff-X is a reliable choice for various projects, appreciated for its professional results and user-friendly properties.
