Tikkurila Optiva paints are lauded by decorators for their quality and versatility. Two of their standout options, Optiva 3 and Optiva 5, are frequently discussed for their suitability in various projects. Optiva 3 offers a flat matt finish, while Optiva 5 is designed for durability with a slight sheen. This review, based on feedback from professional decorators, delves into their performance, strengths, and areas for improvement.
Optiva 3: The Flatter Alternative
Pros
- Dead Flat Finish: Decorators like Lee A praise Optiva 3 for its “dead flat finish,” which is perfect for achieving a modern, minimalist look. Many decorators favour it for dark colours like Hague Blue, as it enhances richness and depth without sheen interference.
- Durability Despite Matt Finish: Despite being a flat matt, Optiva 3 holds up well under light cleaning. Lisa A noted it’s “far more washable than vinyl matt,” and many decorators feel it competes well with other “durable matt” products.
- Hides Imperfections: Optiva 3 is often recommended for walls with slight imperfections. As Dave P pointed out, the lower sheen level helps obscure plastering flaws that Optiva 5 might highlight.
Cons
- Coverage Issues with Lighter Colours: Decorators reported challenges with light colours, particularly whites. For instance, Alex T noted that it took “3 coats of Optiva 3 in white to achieve full opacity,” which can add time and cost to projects.
- Not as Easy to Scrub: While Optiva 3 is durable, it isn’t as scrub-friendly as Optiva 5. Richard I noted it may “polish up when scrubbed.”
- Challenging on Plasterboard Joints: Lisa A observed that Optiva 3 can emphasise imperfections on plasterboard joints compared to Optiva 5, which some decorators might find limiting for new builds.
Optiva 5: The Durable Workhorse
Pros
- Durability and Cleanability: Optiva 5 is favoured for its durability and resistance to scrubbing, making it suitable for high-traffic areas. As Darren F put it, “It’s quite reasonable if you’re a pro club member,” especially given its robust performance.
- Great for Dark Colours: Many decorators, including Alan Y, highlighted Optiva 5’s ability to maintain a rich, even finish in darker colours. The slight sheen adds depth while resisting marks.
- Versatility: Decorators like Northandsons NE value its adaptability, using it extensively for both residential and commercial projects. Its balance between sheen and durability makes it a go-to for care homes, kitchens, and hallways.
Cons
- Roller Marks and Flashing: Roller marks are a frequent complaint. Michael G expressed frustration with roller flashing, even after three coats. He speculated that lighting angles and plaster quality contributed, but the sheen level may also play a role.
- Struggles on Poor Substrates: Walls with subpar plasterwork can exacerbate issues. Ian W and Simon P both noted that Optiva 5’s slight sheen tends to highlight imperfections, making surface prep essential.
- Coverage Concerns: Although durable, decorators like Ben W found its coverage lacking, particularly in lighter shades. “Natural Hessian over Magnolia took 3 coats,” he shared, expressing disappointment given its premium price.
Common Themes in Feedback
Sheen and Light Sensitivity
Optiva 3’s flat finish is a clear winner for reducing light sensitivity and hiding imperfections. In contrast, Optiva 5’s sheen can be a double-edged sword—adding depth to dark colours but potentially accentuating surface flaws under angled light.
Importance of Substrate Preparation
Both paints perform best on well-prepared surfaces. Many decorators stressed the importance of using Optiva Primer or equivalent products to ensure proper adhesion and even coverage. As Pete C highlighted, “Skipping the primer can lead to peeling and adhesion issues.”
Additives for Better Application
Several professionals recommended using Floetrol to improve the flow of both Optiva 3 and 5, especially for challenging applications. Stephen L’s advice to “add 4-5 egg cups of Floetrol per 2.5L” resonated with decorators struggling with flashing or roller marks.
Comparisons to Competitors
Optiva paints face stiff competition from brands like Isomat Premium and Johnstone’s Durable Matt. Decorators often debate these alternatives for their opacity, durability, and cost-effectiveness. Isomat Premium, in particular, received praise for its consistent two-coat coverage.
Recommendations
When to Choose Optiva 3:
- For rooms requiring a flat, matt finish with minimal light reflection.
- Ideal for darker shades or feature walls where sheen might detract from the aesthetic.
- Best for areas with minor surface imperfections.
When to Choose Optiva 5:
- For high-traffic areas where durability and scrub resistance are priorities.
- Suitable for kitchens, bathrooms, and hallways.
- Recommended for darker colours where a slight sheen enhances visual appeal.
Final Thoughts
Tikkurila Optiva 3 and 5 remain popular choices among professional decorators for their unique qualities. While Optiva 3 excels in delivering a modern, flat finish, Optiva 5 offers durability and versatility for more demanding environments. However, coverage issues and the need for meticulous preparation highlight the importance of understanding their limitations. By carefully considering the project’s requirements and using appropriate techniques, decorators can achieve impressive results with these premium emulsions.
